Filter by
The Military History Society of New South Wales

'Breaker' Morant: Just Deserts or Justice Denied?

Where
Anzac Memorial
Anzac Memorial
Southern end of Hyde Park, Sydney NSW 2000
When

Saturday 5 February 2022 from 11am to 12pm

Cost

Free

A Public Lecture by James Unkles, lawyer, author, Commander of the Royal Australian Naval Reserve (Ret'd) and former military legal officer.

From October 1899 a bitter conflict between the British and two Dutch South African republics (the Anglo-Boer War) raged across the South African veldt.

British Commander Lord Roberts left South Africa before the end of 1900 and declared victory. But the war was far from over. His successor Lord Kitchener knew a change of strategy was necessary to fight an effective guerrilla insurgency. He introduced a scorched earth policy of burning farms and crops, and concentration camps to remove non-combatants from the field.

Excesses in war and brutal treatment of prisoners are synonymous with human conflict. This war was no exception. Incidents of brutality, including summary executions, occurred on both sides.

Increasingly desperate, Kitchener turned to the Bushveldt Carbineers (mostly Australians) who successfully played the Boers at their own game.

Yet their operations resulted in the arrest, trial and sentencing of Lieutenants Harry Morant, Peter Handcock (from Bathurst, NSW) and George Witton for killing Boer prisoners. The men claimed they acted in good faith, following the orders of British superiors. They pleaded the principle of reprisal, a defence recognised by the military law of 1902. Still, Morant and Handcock were executed by firing squad on 27 February 1902, a scene famously depicted in Bruce Beresford’s movie.

Critics of the men say they were lawfully convicted of serious war crimes. Their descendants and others complain they were scapegoated. It is also alleged Kitchener conspired to deny them fair trials and kept the proceedings secret from the Australian Government. Defence counsel Major James Thomas (from Tenterfield, NSW) was only appointed the day before. While the men admitted to shooting Boer prisoners, they had a right to trial in accordance with the laws of 1902. They were denied a right of appeal and to state a military redress of grievance to the Crown.

Why does this need to be resolved? 

“The passing of time and the fact that Morant, Handcock and Witton are deceased does not diminish errors in the administration of justice. Injustices in times of war are inexcusable and it takes vigilance to right wrongs, to honour those unfairly treated and to demonstrate respect for the rule of law. This matter involves injustice and how we respond is a test of our values and treatment of these Australian veterans. Their descendants, including those of Thomas and those who respect the rule of law await justice and that must be put above all other considerations”.

This Morant affair remains controversial. James Unkles will speak about the case and his continuing efforts to have it reviewed by an authority independent of government. This would finally determine whether the men were tried according to law and received a fair trial and sentences.

Admission is free of charge but a donation would be appreciated. For further information call 0419 698 783 or email president@militaryhistorynsw.com.au

Contact event organiser

The Military History Society of New South Wales

Accessibility

Advertisement

Other events at Anzac Memorial

Book Fair

Book Fair

The RUSI NSW Ursula Davidson Library is holding a book fair until 1 July 2024
Today 10am to 2am
Frontline Yoga at the Anzac Memorial

Frontline Yoga at the Anzac Memorial

Australia's first and only National Yoga Program for First Responders, Emergency Services and Military Veterans
Today 5.30pm to 6.30pm
HERstory: Remembering Australia’s Military Women

HERstory: Remembering Australia’s Military Women

Honouring the service and sacrifice of Australian servicewomen, featuring the photography of Carla Edwards
Today 9am to 5pm
Indigneous Veterans Commemoration Service

Indigneous Veterans Commemoration Service

Annual Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Servicemen and Servicewomen Commemoration Service
31 May 2024